The Montreal bagel and the New York bagel have almost nothing in common. The Montreal one is smaller, thinner and has a wider hole. Its flavor is sweet (honey and eggs) while the New York one is salty (salt and malt).
The Montreal recipe never contains salt — that's the fundamental distinction. The bagels are boiled in honey-sweetened water, not salted water. And most importantly, they're baked in a wood-fired oven (never an electric one), which produces that smoky flavor impossible to replicate.
The result: a crispy crust with a smoky flavor, a dense, soft interior, and that subtle honey taste that makes the Montreal bagel a one-of-a-kind food.
